The struggle for the authentic inner voice: St. Newman's conscience versus contemporary chaos.
INTRODUCTION: Conscience on Trial
In contemporary society, there is a pervasive mantra that echoes through various platforms: “Follow your truth.” This compelling slogan encourages individuals to embrace their personal beliefs and feelings, but it often drowns out the quieter, yet more profound, voice of God. St. John Henry Newman emerged as a formidable defender against the misapplication of conscience, advocating for a deeper understanding of its true nature.
For Newman, conscience is not merely a personal refuge from absolute truth; rather, it serves as the inner voice of the Divine Lawgiver, resonating within each individual's soul. As we embark on this exploration, it is crucial to rediscover this foundational Catholic teaching, distinguishing between the genuine voice of God and the deceptive allure of personal convenience. As stated in John 10:27, “My sheep hear my voice, and I know them, and they follow me,” it is a call to discernment.
I. What Newman Really Taught About Conscience
Conscience is the “Aboriginal Vicar of Christ”
St. Newman called conscience the "aboriginal Vicar of Christ," indicating that it is an innate, divinely endowed inner voice that exists before all human institutions. Conscience acts as a natural, God-given guide to moral understanding, not a human creation. This essential trait makes conscience the primary way God teaches humans about right and wrong, even before any formal revelation or doctrine.
Conscience, according to Newman, is a sacred faculty, holding a status beyond that of mere cognitive processing or emotional instinct. It is more than a fleeting thought; it is the fundamental core of human moral awareness. As highlighted in Romans 2:15, “They show that what the law requires is written on their hearts, while their conscience also bears witness,” this divine inscription guides individuals toward a moral truth, establishing conscience as an essential element of human dignity.
Conscience is a Voice, Not a Vibe
It is critical to clarify that not every internal sensation or feeling can be classified as conscience. Newman correlates conscience with a moral judgment; it is an evaluative process that prompts actions based on ethical standards, rather than mere emotions, desires, or fears. True conscience always reflects upon what ought to be done, distinguishing itself from transient feelings or personal impulses.
A pivotal insight from Newman’s teachings is that he did not prioritise personal subjectivity over objective moral truths; instead, he emphasised a profound interior obedience to these absolutes. In making moral decisions, one's actions should align with universal truths rather than fleeting personal feelings.
II. Subjective License vs. Conscience Formed in Truth
In modern culture, subjectivism often reigns supreme, with the prevalent mantra being, “If I feel it, it must be right.” This contemporary understanding equates conscience with personal preference, emotional comfort, or social acceptance. Phrases such as “I feel peace about it” are mistaken for moral clarity, obscuring the vital distinction between subjective emotional states and objective morality. Proverbs 14:12 warns us, “There is a way that seems right to a man, but in the end, it leads to death,” underlining the potential dangers of unchecked subjective moral reasoning.
St. Newman’s Response
St. Newman acknowledges that when an individual’s conscience leads them to make a choice, even if it is erroneous, they must adhere to that conscience. However, it is equally essential to note that forming one’s conscience correctly is a serious and solemn duty. An uninformed conscience cannot claim innocence if its ignorance springs from willful negligence or a refusal to seek the truth. As emphasised in Proverbs 24:12, “If you say, ‘Look, we did not know this,’ does not he who weighs the heart perceive it?” highlights the importance of actively pursuing moral understanding.
III. Church Teaching: Conscience is Sacred, but Not Infallible
As articulated in the Catechism of the Catholic Church (CCC), it is essential to recognise that conscience is deeply sacred yet not infallible. According to CCC 1776, “Deep within his conscience man discovers a law which he has not laid upon himself... To obey it is the very dignity of man.” Furthermore, CCC 1790 states, “A human being must always obey the certain judgment of his conscience.” However, this does not grant a license to maintain ignorance; as outlined in CCC 1791-1793, a person bears moral responsibility if they choose to remain in culpable ignorance and neglect the pursuit of truth.
Gaudium et Spes 16 poignantly notes, “Conscience is the most secret core and sanctuary of a man. There he is alone with God, whose voice echoes in his depths.” This assertion reiterates the divine nature of conscience, ensuring that it reflects God’s will as we strive to align with it. In summary, conscience is not self-generated; it is inscribed by God within us. It is not infallible; it requires careful and diligent formation. Lastly, it is not independent of the Church; it must always be aligned with the revealed truth as demonstrated through Scripture and Sacred Tradition.
IV. How to Form a Catholic Conscience
1. Study Sacred Scripture and the Catechism
To truly understand truth, one must begin with God’s Word and the official teachings of the Church, rather than relying on subjective opinions or societal trends. As stated in Psalm 119:105, “Your word is a lamp to my feet and a light to my path,” highlighting the guiding power of divine revelation.
2. Engage in Prayer and Silence
In an era filled with constant noise and distractions, clarity often becomes lost. Only through moments of silence can one truly attune to God’s whisper. Psalm 46:10 reminds us, “Be still and know that I am God,” emphasising the necessity of quiet reflection for proper discernment.
3. Seek Wise Counsel
Engaging with spiritual direction, confession, and guidance from Catholic mentors is crucial, as these external insights provide protection against potential interior deceptions. Proverbs 15:22 wisely states, “Without counsel plans fail, but with many advisers they succeed,” highlighting the importance of community and shared wisdom in moral decision-making.
4. Examine One’s Life Regularly
Implementing a daily examen, or reflective practice, trains the conscience to recognise and correct subtle compromises in ethics and behaviour. This practice aligns with the exhortation in 2 Corinthians 13:5, “Test yourselves to see whether you are in the faith,” encouraging ongoing self-reflection and growth.
V. Conscience in Action: Concrete Catholic Examples
1. A Doctor Who Refuses to Perform Abortions
This medical professional’s conscience firmly holds that life is sacred from the moment of conception, as underscored by Jeremiah 1:5: “Before I formed you in the womb, I knew you.” Her adherence to this belief reflects the importance of conscience in the medical field, prioritising ethical standards over societal pressures.
2. A Student Who Refuses to Cheat
Even in an environment where others may engage in dishonesty, this student stands firm in their commitment to integrity, accepting the possibility of failing as a consequence. Proverbs 19:1 articulates that “Better is the poor who walks in his integrity than one who is perverse in his lips and is a fool,” illustrating the value of ethical choices even in adverse circumstances.
3. A Catholic Who Defies Immoral Laws
Like the martyrs who courageously followed God’s law rather than unjust human regulations, this individual exemplifies unwavering fidelity to divine moral directives. As expressed in Acts 5:29, “We must obey God rather than men,” they prioritise their conscientious commitments over external demands.
4. A Politician Who Votes with a Formed Catholic Conscience
This politician acts according to a well-formed conscience, even if it means sacrificing popularity or jeopardising reelection. Their commitment to moral principles demonstrates the importance of aligning political decisions with ethical values.
VI. The Dangers of an Unformed or Corrupted Conscience
@ Warning Signs
- Replacing God’s law with emotional impulses or societal pressures.
- Utilising “conscience” as a justification for sinful behaviours.
- Disregarding Church teachings when making moral deliberations.
- Confusing tolerance with truth, thereby undermining objective morality.
@ Biblical Warnings
The Scriptures provide significant warnings regarding the perils of a corrupted conscience: “Woe to those who call evil good and good evil,” (Isaiah 5:20) reflects the peril of moral confusion. In contrast “Their consciences are seared with a hot iron” (1 Timothy 4:2) underscores the danger of becoming desensitised to moral truths.
@ Consequences
A corrupted conscience inevitably leads to dire consequences, including:
- Moral Collapse: A decline in ethical standards and loss of integrity.
- Spiritual Blindness: An inability to perceive the truth and distinguish right from wrong due to a misaligned conscience.
- Societal Disintegration: Undermining the common good as individuals stray from objective moral truths.
VII. NEWMAN’S FINAL CHALLENGE: Conscience and the Church
It is essential to clarify that Newman did not advocate for placing personal conscience above Church teaching in a Protestant sense. Instead, he posited that a true conscience, well-formed and aligned with divine teaching, will never ultimately contradict the doctrines established by the Church. Newman’s teachings champion the idea that genuine moral discernment leads an individual towards a deeper understanding of truth, which harmonises rather than conflicts with Church teachings.
Conclusion
We are called to cultivate our consciences, recognising them as a sacred gift that requires formation, guidance, and alignment with God’s enduring truths. In doing so, we can navigate the complexities of moral decision-making with clarity and faithfulness to the divine law inscribed within us.
Old Gandarvakottai,
Pudukottai - 613301.
Comments
Post a Comment